Much of the Nationals' ill fortune in 2009 could be attributed to poor defense. However, as colleague Jeff Bergin points out, it was the pitching that most conspicuously let the team down.
It's hard to fathom a staff so inept that its cumulative Value Over Replacement Player (VORP) is less than zero -- but such, as Jeff reminds us, is what the Nats' was this past season, alone in '09 in Major League Baseball. This confirms what you might have suspected even as early as 2009 Spring Training: that the Nats could have set aside all their Opening Day pitchers save John Lannan, fielded a randomly selected group of triple-A arms, and expected to do no worse than the 59 wins the staff managed to cobble together.
That's more or less what, in fact, they ended up doing as the 2009 season unfolded and unraveled -- due in no small part to the prompt collapse of Daniel Cabrera and the loss of Scott Olsen and Jordan Zimmermann to midseason injuries. Look who started the last four games: Livan Hernandez, who was picked up in August off the Mets' ash heap; Ross Detwiler, who opened his 2009 campaign at double-A Harrisburg; and Garrett Mock and JD Martin, each of whom began his season at triple-A Syracuse.
While Washington won all four of those contests, they have the bullpen to thank for three of those victories. And though that may be good news on the surface, it's far from clear that the 2010 relief corps would benefit from the likes of Zach Segovia and Logan Kensing. Even so, the Nats -- thanks in part to some astute trades and waiver claims, as noted below -- may already have most of the pieces they need to proceed with greater confidence (or less trepidation, anyhow) into the late innings this coming season.
Who are the front-line bullpen candidates for 2010? Try these names on for size.
Middle relief:
- Tyler Clippard started the season alongside Mock and Martin in Syracuse, then came up to South Capitol Street in June and produced 60 1/3 pretty good innings in 41 games, delivering 67 strikeouts, 32 walks, 36 hits and a formidable (if slightly lucky) 2.69 ERA.
- Meanwhile, June trade acquisition Sean Burnett showed greater versatility than your average LOOGY, logging a 3.20 ERA over 33 Washington appearances that ranged in length from one batter to two and a third innings.
- Marco Estrada only had four September outings (totaling seven and a third frames) under the curly W in 2009, but didn't yield an earned run in the last three of those appearances.
- Those of us who've been impressed by the performance of Josh Wilkie at double-A, triple-A and the Arizona Fall League are probably also wondering why Wilkie's been left off Washington's 40-man roster and thus exposed to next month's Rule 5 Draft (an omission it's
not too late to fix [UPDATED 11/27/09: rosters were frozen on November 20; thanks to commenter Rich for pointing out the error]). - If his progress remains steady, Atahualpa Severino shouldn't need more than another year's seasoning to earn a trip to Nats Park.
- The swingman of the future could be Jesse English, whom the Nats snatched off waivers in September from the pitching-rich Giants.
Lefty specialist: If Burnett isn't slotted for this job, it most likely isn't on account of early-September trade acquisition Victor Garate. Recent waiver-wire pickup Doug Slaten would seem a more likely call to get the out when there's one out to get, allowing the Nats to use Burnett more flexibly (and sensibly).
Setup/closer: Washington's 2009 number-two draftee Drew Storen just completed another awe-inspiring stage in his steady ascent, posting a 0.66 ERA in 13 2/3 innings over 12 appearances in the Arizona Fall League. Whether or not Storen starts 2010 in Syracuse, he's unlikely to end it there -- and once he does arrive at Nats Park, the only question will be how near the end of the game he'll be brought in and for how long. If the Nats sign a veteran big-gamer like 38-year-old Billy Wagner or try to charm another decent season out of Mike MacDougal, then Storen will most likely be limited to eighth-inning setup duty. That, however, would probably be just a phase: the 2009 Nats under pitching coach Steve McCatty were willing on occasion to use their relief ace for more than three outs, and there's no reason not to continue that practice as soon as they deem Storen's arm ready for it.
Tags: Scott Olsen, Mike MacDougal, Billy Wagner, Victor Garate, Drew Storen, Doug Slaten, Garrett Mock, San Francisco Giants, J. D. Martin, Harrisburg Senators, Ross Detwiler, New York Mets, Livan Hernandez, John Lannan, pitching, Jeff Bergin, Syracuse Chiefs, Zach Segovia, Logan Kensing, Tyler Clippard, trades, Sean Burnett, Marco Estrada, Arizona Fall League, Josh Wilkie, Rule 5 Draft, First-Year Player Draft, Atahualpa Severino, Montreal Expos, Steve McCatty, Jesse English, Jordan Zimmermann, Daniel Cabrera